image1 image2 image3
Home Press Movie News and Reviews Oranges And Sunshine - Little White Lies (31mar11)


Oranges And Sunshine - Little White Lies (31mar11) PDF Print E-mail
Laura Bushell
March 31, 2011

Wearing its social conscience well and truly on its sleeve, this theatrical debut from esteemed TV director Jim Loach (son of Ken) hardly breaks the family filmmaking mould. But that’s not to disparage the director’s talents in bringing this extraordinary tale to the screen with a measured and very subtle approach.

Oranges and Sunshine tells the personal stories behind the apologies issued by the British and Australian governments to thousands of British children in care who were systematically shipped to Australia and other Commonwealth countries over nigh-on a hundred years until the 1970s.

It was a shady little secret until the 1980s, when a Nottinghamshire social worker began to make contact with the victims, some of whom were as young as four-years-old when they were told their parents were dead before being shipped out, alone, on a boat to a ‘better place’. Not only were some of the children’s parents very much alive, but the institutions in which they were placed were more often than not physically, mentally or sexually abusive. All this in the name of saving a few pounds.

Of course, taking inspiration from real life on such an emotive issue as forced child migration has its downfall in the fact that a pre-existing story must be adhered to, lest the filmmaker upset those involved in the real world. Apparently, social worker Margaret Humphreys (Emily Watson), took eight years to acquiesce to her shocking story being given the screen treatment. And not only does the film have to remain faithful to her version of events, but to those still dealing with the consequences of being robbed of their childhood.

Although packing emotional clout, the story is sometimes stretched thinly across the film’s 102 minutes and at times lacks the drama that more fiction would produce, especially in relation to Humphreys’ own family versus the amount of time she had to devote to helping others trace theirs.

Sure, her husband and children were saint-like in dealing with her absence in the name of a very good cause, but at times there’s a certain lack of friction, which would have helped shape the film into something more cinematic.

Perhaps this story would have been better suited to television rather than the cinema, but for his biographical screen debut Loach has at least secured some top-notch acting talent. Watson is on understated, dignified form as Humphreys, with Hugo Weaving giving a particularly affecting turn as a victim who may never escape the childhood he was forced to endure.

There’s a lot to be said for such heart-wrenching drama that doesn’t fall into the easy trap of mawkishness or manipulation – Loach has cast actors capable of dealing with raw scenes in a spare yet deeply moving way.

Anticipation:
Loach by name and, looking at the storyline for this one, Loach by nature, too. Anticipation Score

Enjoyment:
Enjoyment is a funny word to use in this context, ‘emotional absorption’ might be better. Enjoyment Score

In Retrospect:
Very well put together and no doubt a story needing to be told. This is a solid debut, but the hangover from Loach’s TV past looks large on the big screen. In Retrospect Score

 
 

Current projects

liaisons_dangereuses Les Liaisons Dangereuses
March 2012
Vicompte de Valmont
News | Official Site | Pics| Clips
mrmcgee_trailer.png The Adventures of Mr. McGee
In development
Narrator
News | IMDb | Official Site | Pics| Clips

cloud_atlas.jpg

Cloud Atlas
Post production

Role: tba
News | IMDb | Official Site | Pics| Clips

the_hobbit

The Hobbit
In production
Role:
Elrond
News | IMDb | Official Site | Pics| Clips

happy_feet_two

Happy Feet Two
On DVD
Role: Noah the Elder
News | IMDb | Official Site | Pics| Clips

keyman

The Key Man
Premiere at SXSW March 2011
Role:
Vincent

News | IMDb | Official Site | Pics| Clips

By A Web Design Company